Hourly billing punishes you for being good at your job. The faster you work, the less you earn.
TL;DR Price the outcome, not the clock. Build fixed prices from your real costs plus the value delivered. Define scope in writing or you will give the difference away in scope creep.
The hourly trap, stated plainly
You spend twenty years learning to diagnose a problem in ten minutes. Hourly billing charges for ten minutes.
The three costs of hourly
- Expertise is penalised. The slower operator earns more for the same result.
- Every conversation is a negotiation about time, not about outcome.
- Your income is capped at hours available multiplied by rate. There is a ceiling and you will hit it.
And customers hate it too. Hourly means an unknown final number, which is the thing people fear most about hiring a trade.
Fixed pricing is the first move, not value pricing
Most businesses trying to jump straight to value pricing fail because they skip the middle step.
| Stage | Model | What it needs |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hourly | Nothing |
| 2 | Fixed price per job type | Knowing your true costs |
| 3 | Tiered fixed pricing | Packaging skill |
| 4 | Value pricing | Ability to quantify customer outcome |
Get to stage 2 first. Fixed pricing alone solves most of the hourly problem and it is achievable this month.
Know your true cost before you price anything
You cannot price up from a number you do not have.
Per job, calculate
- Direct labour, including payroll tax and benefits, not just wage.
- Drive time, both ways. This is the most commonly ignored cost.
- Materials, at your real cost including waste.
- Equipment, depreciated per use.
- Overhead allocation. Insurance, vehicle, software, phone, rent, admin time, divided across your billable jobs.
- Non-billable time. Quoting, invoicing, chasing payment, ordering. Frequently 30% or more of the week.
That last one destroys most pricing models. If you bill 25 hours in a 45-hour week, your true cost per billable hour is nearly double what you think.
Build the fixed price
- Take your true cost for that job type.
- Add your target margin.
- Sense-check against the value to the customer, not against competitors.
- Set the price and publish it.
The value check is where the upside lives. A $400 repair that prevents $9,000 of water damage is not priced against other $400 repairs. It is priced against the alternative.
Value mapping, practically
For each service, write down:
- What it costs them not to fix it. Damage, downtime, higher bills, worse failure later.
- What it saves or earns them. Efficiency, reliability, resale value.
- What the alternative costs. The bigger job they avoid.
- What the risk is if it is done badly.
Then price inside that gap, comfortably below the cost of the problem and comfortably above your cost of delivery.
Communicating fixed pricing
The change is easier to sell than owners expect, because customers prefer it.
The script
We price by the job, not by the hour. You get one number before we start and that is what you pay, unless we find something we could not see and you approve the change in writing. No surprises either way.
What that does. Removes their biggest fear, positions you as confident, and sets up the change-order process in the same breath.
Do not explain your costs. Nobody buys a plumber based on your insurance premium. Price the outcome and let the number stand.
Scope creep will eat the difference
Fixed pricing without defined scope is a trap you set for yourself.
- Write the scope in the quote. What is included, what is explicitly not.
- Name the exclusions. “Does not include drywall repair or repainting.”
- Set a change-order process and use it every time, without exception.
- Get the change approved in writing before doing the work. A text message counts.
- Price the change. Never absorb it “to keep them happy,” because that is where fixed pricing quietly becomes hourly at a discount.
The one that matters. “While you are here, could you just…” That sentence is where the profit goes. The answer is “yes, that would be $X, want me to add it?”
Migrating existing clients
- New customers get the new model immediately.
- Existing customers move on their next job, not retroactively.
- Give notice if they are on a regular arrangement.
- Do not apologise. Explain it as an improvement, because for them it is.
What to expect
Some customers leave. Usually the ones optimising purely for the lowest hourly number, who were your least profitable work.
Your average job value rises, because you stop discounting expertise by being fast.
Quoting gets faster, because you are selecting from known prices rather than estimating hours.
Price your three most common jobs as fixed prices this week, using your real costs including drive time and non-billable hours. That single calculation usually reveals you have been underpricing by more than you would like to know.
Need a pro to model it? [BOOK A CALL]