For insurance agencies ยท Marketing planning
A plan for more policies per household.
Agencies grow by writing more lines per client and keeping them at renewal. Chasing raw quote volume is the expensive way to grow.
Or text (508) 546-9942
Slide it
You vs. Average Joe Insurance.
Left is your website today. Right is the one Average Joe Insurance has. Drag the line, then hit the button.
Crickets on the left. That is the problem.
Welcome To Our Web Site
Visitors: 000417
Copyright 2014 · call 508-555-0123 · best viewed in a browser
Illustration. Joe is made up. Your competitor is not.
The insurance agency version
Why it matters.
An agency writes plenty of auto and has a steady stream of quote requests. But the book is mostly single-policy households, and every renewal cycle some of them leave over price. The plan looks at that book and asks the uncomfortable question: is the problem finding new clients, or keeping and rounding out the ones you already have? More often than owners expect, it is the second.
Strategy for an agency also means choosing a lane. Personal lines, small commercial, a niche like contractors or restaurants, or a specialty like coastal homes. Independent agencies can promise market access. Captive agencies compete on relationship and the carrier's name. The plan writes down which you are and who you serve best.
What I would build
For an insurance agency.
What you sell, to whom, and why you over the carrier's direct website or the agency down the road. Specific enough to put on the homepage and say on the phone.
When each client hears from you, what triggers a coverage review, and which second policy makes sense for which household. A weekly rhythm your staff can keep.
Realtors, mortgage brokers, auto dealers, contractors, accountants. I pick a couple of partner types that fit your lines and plan how you stay on their minds.
Policies per household, retention at renewal, and quotes that actually bound. The threshold that triggers a change, and a review date already on the calendar.
The mistake I see
Measuring quotes instead of bound policies
Quote volume looks great in a report. It says nothing about whether those were the right risks, whether anyone followed up, or whether they bound. Agencies chasing quote counts buy lead lists, flood producers with poor fits and burn out the team. Measure bound policies and retention. The plan is built around those two.
What you get
Marketing planning.
Before anybody designs anything, I figure out what you are selling, to whom, and what has to happen every week.
- A written position: what you sell, to whom, and why you over the alternative
- The offer, defined tightly enough to put a price on
- Which channels get effort and which get ignored
- A weekly rhythm somebody can actually keep
- What gets measured, and the threshold that triggers a decision
How it goes
For an insurance agency, step by step.
→ Keep scrolling. It moves sideways.
One long conversation
Your numbers, your best customers, the jobs you wish you had more of.
Narrow it
Most plans fail from doing six things badly. I pick two.
Write it down
One page. If it needs ten, it will not survive a busy month.
Set the review
A date to look at it honestly and change it.
Step five is you.
The free Receipt shows what your insurance agency should fix first. About half a minute, no card.
Print my Receipt →
Questions
What insurance agencies ask.
Should we buy insurance leads?
Purchased leads are often sold to several agencies at once, so it turns into a race to call first. Some agencies make that work with very tight follow-up. Many do better putting the same money into their own website, reviews and referral partners, where the lead belongs to them alone. The plan weighs both against your capacity.
Is it worth specializing in a niche?
Often, yes. A niche gives referral partners an easy sentence: call them for contractors, or for coastal homes. It also lets your website and ads speak clearly to one kind of client. The risk is carrier appetite. Make sure the markets you write will keep taking that business before you build a brand around it.
How do we handle rate increases in our marketing?
Honestly, and before the client sees the bill. A short message ahead of renewal, explaining that rates are moving if they are, and offering a review, keeps the conversation with you instead of a comparison site. Never promise to bring the price down. Promise to look.
Everything else
Other services for insurance agencies.
Same service
Marketing planning for other businesses.
Where I work
Southeastern Massachusetts and Rhode Island.
Start here
See what your customers see.
The Receipt looks your insurance agency up the way a customer would and itemizes what is costing you calls. It is free. Or skip it and book fifteen minutes with me.
Or text (508) 546-9942